Facebook vs Orkut vs Yahoo! Mash vs MySpace, and some other Social Networking sites

Category: How Products benefit users 2 Comments »

Social Network Sites

Facebook

Facebook logo

73.5 million users and growing fastest

What I like about it

  1. Mini-Feed is useful in seeing a quick snapshot on the latest happenings within your network without going to several sites to check.
  2. The ability to supply how you know a person.
  3. Nice applications. Approximately 10% of Facebook applications I’ve tried are interesting and useful while others are not as good.

I think these can be improved

  1. Fixed 600 width and non-resizable
  2. Non-customizable design
  3. No built-in blogging functionality. Blogging can be done with applications such as Live Blog, but we don’t normally depend on addons for such important values like blogs.
  4. Tight security: profile only viewable by friends. How do you determine if a profile is your friend or not just by looking at the screen name which can be different from the real name?
  5. One account can only join no more than 200 groups. Unlimited is preferred.

Orkut

Glossy Orkut logo

24.6 million users

What I like about it

  1. Simple design, Google philosophy after all
  2. Extensible width
  3. Ad-free

I think these can be improved

  1. Name. Honestly speaking, the Turkish name “Orkut” is very unfamiliar. Just a remark, as the brand name is not supposed to change
  2. Very few, if any, extensions

Yahoo! Mash

Yahoo! Mash Logo

What I like about it

  1. Wider width
  2. Larger font
  3. Allows profiles to be updated by friends
  4. Mini-feed is also supplied

I think these can be improved

  1. Check boxes to select friends to add should be provided
  2. More group levels
  3. Informal language. I am especially not easy with the word “fugly”
  4. Profile with non-removable fields such as “What’s most likely playing on my iPod”… Excuse me, can I NOT have an iPod?

MySpace

MySpace logo

107 million users. The currently largest site

What I like about it

  1. Integrated all-in-one solution that includes social networking, blogging, mail, favorites, forum, movies, events, media

I think these can be improved

  1. Inconsistent design
  2. Music landing page
  3. Spam, including spam invitations, protection
  4. Tons of ads

Other notable networking sites

Name Focus Number of users (in million) Comments
Windows Live Spaces Blogging 120 Really eye-catching glossy design. Powerful blogging support. Try new Microsoft experience!
hi5 General 50 An issue: the letter ‘5′ creates this word “hị” in Vietnamese. hi5 is still nice anyway
bebo Schools & alumni 34 Nice and neat
friendster General 50 Friendster is getting old. It needs more innovation.
imeem Media: Music, Video 16 Possibly the best media site currently. Nice design and convenient upload process. Support tagging
LinkedIn Business 15 Very professional for business networking purpose
Last.fm Music 15 Attractive design, especially the logo. However, radio alone is not that fascinating. They could use more of music sharing
Xanga Blogging 40 The ad on top is a huge barrier to this site’s design. Usability is a little messy

Read more

Wikipedia, List of social networking websites

Mashable, Facebook Hammers MySpace on Almost All Key Features

Techcrunch, Facebook platform

American Class Divisions

Nerdlifestyle, Media restrictions

My choice

Facebook to keep in touch with international friends and English-speaking communities

Yahoo! Mash. Many young Vietnamese users rely on Yahoo! services

Tai Tran on iMeem for socially musical networking

How about you?

Share your experience here…

Which site do you like best? What you wish your site had offered?




Tags of this article: ,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,.


Last update October 29, 2007

Related Posts


  • Facebook vs. Orkut in Photo sharing

  • Facebook tries to solve Privacy problems

  • Inbox 2.0: Yahoo and Google to Turn E-Mail Into a Social Network

  • Yahoo! New Profile creates no buzz!!!

  • Yahoo!, take the LITTLE advantage you have over Facebook!
  • Digg this post | Post to Reddit | Post this post to del.icio.us | Favorite this post on Technorati | Stumble Upon this post | Bookmark on Yahoo! | Share on Facebook | Bookmark on Google

    Youtube Usability Improvable

    Category: How Products benefit users No Comments »

    Dear Youtube logo

    I love your wonderful service.

    But I’ll love yours even more if you can make it quicker and clearer for me to upload videos.

    1. Uploading Process

    Problem: uploading process takes 2 steps

    Solution: merge these 2 steps into one single page

    Advantage: save users one screen load

    2. Required field indicator

    Problem: no indicator to distinguish required fields

    Solution: put an asterisk beside each required field

    Advantage: avoid confusion for users

    3. Error message

    Problem: very general and confusing “Please double-check your video title”.

    Solution: “Title is required”

    Advantage: avoid confusion of users

    Upload process to youtube

    Other Youtube users, what do you think of my suggestions? Please share your experience in the comments…

    Thanks a lot




    Tags of this article: ,,,,,,,.


    Last update October 17, 2007

    Related Posts


  • Sorting Data in Microsoft Word 2007

  • Post YouTube video on hosted WordPress blog

  • YouTube launched new Player

  • Tai Tran on Yahoo! Pipes

  • Localization must allow option to International version
  • Digg this post | Post to Reddit | Post this post to del.icio.us | Favorite this post on Technorati | Stumble Upon this post | Bookmark on Yahoo! | Share on Facebook | Bookmark on Google

    New Yahoo! Mail ends Beta

    Category: How Products benefit users 1 Comment »

    New Yahoo! Mail ends Beta

    Recap of new features

    Though you might have experienced them already. I’ll make a quick recap when the new Yahoo! Mail turns official and becomes default.

    New hot keys

    Although Yahoo! Mail classic already provided hot keys and prompts, new Yahoo! Mail makes them shorter thus more memorable.

    Tabs

    Tabs come into place. Now we have different tabs for each of our task, whether it is reading different messages or composing different letters.

    Integrated RSS reader

    It allows you to forward a post as an email.

    Unlimited Storage

    I still remembered the time when we used to have only 4Mb per account. It was only 4 years ago. Time flies any now we have more and more and more storage due to cheaper hardware.

    In 2007, storage is no longer a big concern of users. At the time of this post, Hotmail already offers 5Gb, Gmail will be offering 4Gb. Nevertheless, unlimited is always nice.

     

     

    Yahoo! Mail Features

    Integrated Yahoo! Messenger chat

    Though basic, it comes in handy.

    SMS Messaging

    It currently works for U.S., India, Philippines and Canadian mobile numbers.

    More effective spam-filters

    It’s hard to estimate how effective it is, but it works well on my account.

    Built-in Context Menu

    Context Menu refers to a menu that appears when you right-click on a Graphical User Interface element.

    Hint: in some browsers, the browser’s Context Menu is displayed together with Yahoo! Mail Context Menu and is of higher priority. To use Yahoo! Mail Context Menu, hit “Esc” once.

    What I wish Yahoo! had offered

    • Forwarding
      It’s only available with Yahoo! Plus. Gmail offers forwarding for their free account. The strategy is Yahoo! and Google is different so I have to learn to live with it.
    • POP3
      Also available with Yahoo! Plus

    How I use different email services

    I tried around 40 free email services in 2003. I now narrow down to one Yahoo! Mail, one Gmail, one Hotmail and some email accounts on my professional website taitran.com

    1. Yahoo! Mail and other Yahoo! services such 360 are for staying in touch with my personal networks
    2. Gmail is for more professional connections such as organizations, societies
    3. The Hotmail account is more exploring Microsoft Live, MSN and Hotmail
    4. My professional email at taitran dot com is for occasions when branding is really important

    Which email services do you use? Do you use different email services for different purpose?




    Tags of this article: ,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,.


    Last update October 16, 2007

    Related Posts


  • Zing Mail Beta, unlimited storage, 30Mb attachment

  • Tai Tran’s Choices (and dilemma) of Media

  • Inbox 2.0: Yahoo and Google to Turn E-Mail Into a Social Network

  • Quick Updates on Vietnamese Social Networking Sites

  • Yahoo! Mail 2007 shortcuts
  • Digg this post | Post to Reddit | Post this post to del.icio.us | Favorite this post on Technorati | Stumble Upon this post | Bookmark on Yahoo! | Share on Facebook | Bookmark on Google

    WP Theme & Icons by N.Design Studio